"Reynolds' book is a lucidly written and unique contribution to the study of Islam. By highlighting scholarly perspectives on Muhammad and the Qur'an in an accessible and well-researched manner, Reynolds has provided students and general readers with a remarkable resource. His insights into Muslim discussions about Islamic faith in contemporary times provide a stimulating introduction to the relevance of history to today's world."
Professor of History
University of Victoria
"Reynolds has managed a veritable tour de force
. He has produced an introduction to Islam that combines a solid critical approach with a genuine respect for the traditional Muslim account of Islamic origins. Reynolds offers a careful treatment of Islam's historical origins, an introduction to the literary genres of Qur'an, Hadith
, history, and Sira
, and the methodological interrelationships of these literatures. Reynolds effectively turns the traditional approach to Qur'an and history on its head, showing how the Qur'an becomes the historical context of the Sira
's emergence rather than the latter providing the reasons for the revelation of the Qur'an. This book will undoubtedly replace one of my required readings next time I teach Introduction to Islam."
Fuller Graduate School of Intercultural Studies
"Reynolds' new book is welcome given the clear, accessible way in which he presents both the classical approach to the study of Islamic origins and the sometimes complicated ways that current scholarship revises our view of Islam. Particularly valuable is his emphasis on early Islam's interaction with other religious traditions in its milieu and with their scriptures, especially Judaism and Christianity. It is a perfect text for introductory courses in Islam and the religions of the Middle East."
—Sidney H. Griffith, S.T.
Professor of Semitic and Egyptian Languages and Literatures
The Catholic University of America
"Gabriel Reynolds's The Emergence of Islam
is highly informative, deeply learned, and very thought-provoking, and lays out well the labyrinthine complexities of the issues surrounding Islam's origins. I especially like the way the author provides both a summary of the traditional Islamic (and Western scholarly) view of Islam's origins, and a look at the critical issues that have propelled the recent wave of revisionist work on early Islam. This book will be especially valuable as a tool for introducing new readers to this fascinating subject".
—-Fred M. Donner
Director, Center for Middle Eastern Studies
Professor of Near Eastern History
University of Chicago
President, Middle East Studies Association of North America, 2011-2012